The song you're likely thinking of is "Gives You Hell" by All-American Rejects. Released in 2005, it was a single from their second studio album, "Move Along."
Gives You Hell Artist: The All-American Rejects Album: When the World Comes Down Release Year: 2008 Genre: Alternative Rock / Power Pop american rejects hope it gives you hell lyrics
"And you're still probably right at the top of the list" The song you're likely thinking of is "Gives
Here's a part of the lyrics: